The Directorate of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has accused Broadhurst Regional Magistrate Mareledi Dipate of misapplying corruption laws and overlooking key evidence when he acquitted former Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy Lefoko Moagi in the P4.7 million corruption case.
In its 11 grounds of appeal, the prosecution argues that Dipate applied the wrong legal test when deciding that Moagi had no case to answer, failed to consider the ministerial discretion at the centre of the alleged corruption and misunderstood the legal significance of money made available to the former minister.
The grounds, filed before the High Court recently, provide a detailed account of why the DPP believes the October 29 acquittal was legally flawed. They challenge several aspects of the magistrate’s judgment, including his treatment of witnesses, statutory presumptions and the role played by Moagi in the approval of prospecting licences.
One of the central arguments concerns the interpretation of Section 180(3) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act, which governs the discharge of an accused person at the close of the prosecution’s case.
The DPP argues that Dipate wrongly acquitted Moagi by applying a standard of whether there was enough evidence rather than whether there was no evidence at all.
According to the prosecution, Section 180(3) permits an acquittal where there is “no evidence” at the end of the State’s case, but does not allow a magistrate to discharge an accused simply because the evidence is considered insufficient.
According to the prosecution, Section 180(3) permits an acquittal where there is “no evidence” at the end of the State’s case, but does not allow a magistrate to discharge an accused simply because the evidence is considered insufficient.
The DPP says Dipate “applied a standard not contemplated by Section 180(3)”, which it describes as “not enough evidence”.
The prosecution also disputes the magistrate’s treatment of the P4.7 million allegedly made available to Moagi through Wise Creatives Investments, a company linked to New Energy Company. It argues that Dipate failed to appreciate that a loan can constitute valuable consideration under Section 23(a) of the Corruption and Economic Crime Act (CECA), meaning that the description of the financial arrangement as a loan does not, in itself, provide a defence to a corruption charge. The grounds state that the magistrate “erred in not appreciating that a loan constitutes valuable consideration in terms of Section 23(a)”.
The DPP further argues that Dipate failed to apply Section 23 despite its relevance to the case. Another contested issue is the prosecution’s failure to call Zheng Li as a witness. In his judgment, Dipate questioned the absence of individuals connected to the companies involved in the transactions. However, the DPP argues that Li was himself a potential accused person or, at best, an accomplice, and that the magistrate was wrong to criticise the State for not calling him.
The prosecution maintains that the principle requiring the State to call witnesses reasonably expected to be relevant to its case does not apply in the same way to potential accused persons and accomplices. The appeal also challenges Dipate’s failure to apply Section 42 of CECA, which provides for a statutory presumption relevant to corruption proceedings. The DPP says the magistrate was aware of the provision but neglected to apply it despite its material relevance to the inquiry.
The State further accuses Dipate of failing to consider the full body of evidence presented during the prosecution’s case. According to the grounds of appeal, 24 witnesses had testified, but the magistrate concentrated on the evidence of only two, identified as PW1 and PW2.
The DPP argues that the magistrate was required by law to consider all the evidence when determining whether Moagi had a case to answer. A substantial part of the appeal concerns the extent of Moagi’s authority in the approval of prospecting licences.
The magistrate had questioned how the former minister could have influenced the award of the licences when junior officials had undertaken due diligence and processed the applications.
The DPP argues that this reasoning overlooked the ministerial discretion vested in Moagi, maintaining that he had the authority to approve or reject applications and was not simply required to sign off on recommendations prepared by officials. The prosecution says Dipate erred by “treating the success of the application as a fait accompli”, arguing that the Minister retained discretion over whether the applications should be approved.
The prosecution has also identified what it considers an inconsistency in the judgment. It argues that Dipate expressly found athat the State had established a prima facie case before subsequently concluding that Moagi had no case to answer. The DPP contends that the two findings are incompatible and constitute a further error of law.
It also challenges the magistrate’s finding that there were no competing applications before Moagi, arguing that there was no evidence before the court to support that conclusion.
The State further disputes the reasoning that the completion of due diligence by junior officers effectively ruled out corruption, arguing that administrative processing of applications did not remove the possibility of wrongdoing at the ministerial approval stage.
The prosecution has also identified what it considers an inconsistency in the judgment. It argues that Dipate expressly found athat the State had established a prima facie case before subsequently concluding that Moagi had no case to answer. The DPP contends that the two findings are incompatible and constitute a further error of law.
Moagi was acquitted on October 29 after the magistrate upheld a no-case-to-answer application by the defence. The case involved allegations that he received P4,706,000 through Wise Creatives Investments in connection with the award of prospecting licences for base metals in Ghanzi, Tsabong and Tutume districts. The prosecution alleged that the financial arrangement was linked to the award of eight prospecting licences. Investigators told the court that Moagi had access to the funds through a Bank Gaborone card and that approximately P1.8 million had been spent using it.
Dipate found that the State had failed to establish sufficient evidence to require Moagi to enter his defence, questioning, among other things, the absence of key witnesses and whether the prosecution had demonstrated that the former minister personally influenced the licensing decisions.



